Eastern vs. Western Caribbean: Best Excursions

Are you torn between an Eastern or Western Caribbean cruise? Each route offers unique landscapes, cultural experiences, and thrilling excursions. Whether you’re drawn to the sun-kissed beaches of the Eastern Caribbean or the ancient ruins and jungles of the Western Caribbean, choosing the right itinerary can make all the difference.

Shore excursions are the key to truly immersing yourself in these tropical paradises and transforming your cruise from a mere vacation into an unforgettable adventure. As a Caribbean junkie myself, I'll break down the best excursions for each region to help you pick the itinerary that aligns with your interests. Read on for help whether you’re up for soaking up the culture, embarking on an adrenaline-filled adventure, or simply relaxing on some of the world's most beautiful beaches.

Key Differences Between Eastern and Western Caribbean Cruises

Geography and Itineraries

Eastern Caribbean cruises typically include stops at destinations like St. Thomas, San Juan, and St. Maarten, with lush landscapes, white-sand beaches, and vibrant towns. These itineraries often have longer sailing days and more time to explore various islands. It’s the quintessential Caribbean experience for those who crave island-hopping.

Conversely, Western Caribbean cruises bring you closer to mainland adventures. You’ll find yourself in ports like Cozumel, Grand Cayman, and Jamaica, where you can explore ancient Mayan ruins, dive into coral reefs, or trek through dense rainforests. The Western route is a fantastic choice if you’re looking for a mix of history, culture, and natural wonders.

Cultural Experiences

The Eastern Caribbean is rich in colonial history, influenced by French, Dutch, Spanish, and British cultures. Wander the cobblestone streets of Old San Juan or admire the Dutch architecture in St. Maarten—each island tells its unique story.

In contrast, the Western Caribbean blends Mayan, African, and Spanish influences. This region offers a more diverse cultural experience, from Belize's ancient ruins to Jamaica's reggae rhythms. For travelers seeking historical depth and cultural variety, the Western Caribbean delivers.

Best Excursions in the Eastern Caribbean

St.Thomas, U.S. Virgin Islands

Best Excursion: Kayaking and Snorkeling in Mangrove Lagoon

If you’re up for some adventure, kayaking through the calm waters of Mangrove Lagoon is a great way to see another side of St. Thomas. You’ll paddle through narrow waterways surrounded by lush mangroves, maybe even catching a glimpse of a shy crab that thinks it’s hiding from you! 

Then, grab your snorkel gear and dive in. Clear waters here reveal vibrant coral, tropical fish, and some stingrays. It’s an easy half-day trip, so you’ll have plenty of time to hit the shops in Charlotte Amalie afterward.

Alternative Excursion: Coral World Ocean Park and Coki Beach

For a more laid-back day, head to Coral World Ocean Park. It’s perfect if you’re traveling with kids or want to explore at your own pace. You can get up close with sea turtles and sharks and even pet a stingray. 

Coki Beach is right next door and it’s considered the best spot for snorkeling on the island. Bring your snorkel gear or rent some on the spot for a beach day with crystal-clear water. If you really just want to take it easy, you can rent loungers and umbrellas, and snacks and drinks are available from the many food stands. Make sure you’ve got enough cash on you, though, as the nearby ATM was broken both times I’ve visited.

San Juan, Puerto Rico

Best Excursion: El Yunque Rainforest Hike and Waterfall Tour

If you’re craving nature, a guided tour of El Yunque Rainforest is necessary. You’ll hike through lush trails, see unique wildlife, and take a refreshing dip in one of the waterfalls. 

It’s a bit of a drive from the port, but this tour offers round-trip transportation, making exploring Puerto Rico’s natural beauty hassle-free. 

Alternative Excursion: Exploring Old San Juan, Including Castillo San Felipe del Morro

Old San Juan is like stepping into a postcard. Spend a few hours wandering the cobblestone streets, checking out the colorful Spanish colonial buildings, and popping into local shops.

Make your way to Castillo San Felipe del Morro, a massive 16th-century fortress with unbeatable ocean views. Wear comfortable shoes—there’s a lot of walking, but the history and photo ops are worth every step.

St. Maarten (Dutch Side) / St. Martin (French Side)

Best Excursion: Maho Beach for Airplane Landings and a Beach Day

Maho Beach is the ultimate spot for a beach day with a twist. Where else can you sunbathe and get a complimentary ‘buzz cut’ from a passing plane? It’s famous for its super low-flying airplanes landing right over your head—seriously, you can feel the jet engines! 

Bring your camera and be ready for a wild experience. After catching some thrilling landings, grab a drink from the nearby beach bars and lounge on the sand. It’s a quick cab ride from the port, so getting back to the ship is as stress-free as can be.

Alternative Excursion: Snorkeling at Creole Rock on the French Side

If you’re more into exploring underwater, head to the French side for a snorkeling trip to Creole Rock. It’s about a 15-minute boat ride offshore, and once you’re there, you’ll find calm waters teeming with colorful fish and coral formations. 

Most tours include gear, snacks, and drinks, so all you need to do is show up and enjoy.

Antigua

Best Excursion: Tour of Nelson’s Dockyard and Snorkeling at Cades Reef

History buffs and beach lovers, this one’s for you! Start with a guided tour of Nelson’s Dockyard, a UNESCO World Heritage site with restored 18th-century naval buildings. It’s a fascinating peek into Antigua’s past. 

Then, hop on a boat to Cades Reef, one of the best snorkeling spots in the Caribbean. On my visit, I spotted three turtles and some stingrays and I was told it’s not rare. It’s a full-day adventure but well worth it.

Alternative Excursion: Catamaran Cruise Around the Island's 365 Beaches

Looking to unwind with the wind in your hair? A catamaran cruise around Antigua’s coast might be your craving escape. Cruise past a few of Antigua’s '365 beaches'—yes, that’s one for every day! 

Swim, sunbathe, and savor a laid-back onboard lunch. It’s a fantastic way to see the island’s beauty without lifting a finger.

Best Excursions in the Western Caribbean

Cozumel, Mexico

Best Excursion: Snorkeling at El Cielo – Swim with Rays and Marine Life

El Cielo is hands-down the top snorkeling spot in Cozumel. I live at nearby Playa del Carmen and whenever I have visitors, this is usually my top pick for a fun day out. The water is so clear that it’s like you're swimming in a giant aquarium with rays, starfish, and tropical fish. 

Most tours take you by boat and provide all the gear, snacks, and drinks—so all you need to bring is your swimsuit, sunscreen, and a sense of adventure. Pro tip: You’ll be in and out of the water all day so if you’re sensitive to the sun, get a swim shirt for the best protection.

Alternative Excursion: Day Trip to Tulum or Chichen Itza Mayan Ruins

Want to dive into some history? Take a ferry and bus combo from Cozumel to the mainland for a day trip to the Tulum or Chichen Itza ruins. Tulum offers stunning ocean views and ancient ruins, while Chichen Itza is one of the World's New Seven Wonders. Be prepared for a long day (around 8-10 hours), but it's worth it for the photo ops and stories you'll bring back.

Belize City, Belize

Best Excursion: River Tubing Through Caves

This combo tour is a crowd-pleaser and one of the more famous tours in Belize City. Cool off with some river tubing through underground caves. You’ll be floating through dark, winding passages with a headlamp—it's super fun and a bit adventurous! 

I suggest packing some water shoes (or grabbing a pair at the dock) as it can be slippery in spots. Also, believe it or not, you might be a bit chilly by the end, so pack something dry and warm to pop on for the trip back.

Alternative Excursion: Snorkeling or Diving at the Belize Barrier Reef

Belize’s Barrier Reef is a must-see if you prefer to stay coastal. Explore top-notch snorkeling and diving tours to Hol Chan Marine Reserve or Shark Ray Alley, where you can swim with nurse sharks and stingrays. 

Most tours include gear and lunch on Caye Caulker where you’ll get a chance to see what island life is like in Belize. It’s one of the most relaxing places I’ve visited in the world so try not to nap for too long after lunch!

Grand Cayman

Best Excursion: Stingray City Sandbar and Snorkeling at Coral Gardens

Stingray City is a classic Grand Cayman experience you shouldn’t miss. You’ll wade into waist-deep, crystal-clear water at a sandbar surrounded by friendly stingrays that swim right up to you. Don’t worry—they’re gentle! 

Afterward, most tours will take you to Coral Gardens for snorkeling, where you can see colorful coral and tropical fish. Make sure to bring your waterproof camera. You’ll spot so many colorful fish that it’ll be tough to know where to look.

Alternative Excursion: Relaxing at Seven Mile Beach

If you’re all about kicking back, head to Seven Mile Beach. You can grab a lounger, rent a jet ski, or walk along the soft, white sand. Beach bars and restaurants are nearby, so you won’t have to wander far for a cold drink or a bite. 

It’s a short drive from the cruise port which is why this is usually my first pick for a beach day on a Caribbean cruise. Time it right and you can go from cruise cabin to beach lounger in less than 20 minutes.

Roatán, Honduras

Best Excursion: Ziplining and Snorkeling at West Bay Beach

Roatán is an adventure-lover’s dream. Start with ziplining through the lush jungle canopy—it’s a total adrenaline rush with amazing views! 

Once you’ve had your fill of flying through the trees, head to West Bay Beach for some of the best snorkeling in the Caribbean. You can rent gear on the beach and swim to see colorful fish and coral reefs. It’s an easy half-day trip, so you can fit in both activities without feeling rushed.

Alternative Excursion: Gumbalimba Park Tour and Wildlife Sanctuary Visit

For a more laid-back day, check out Gumbalimba Park. You’ll walk through botanical gardens, cross a suspension bridge, and visit a wildlife sanctuary where you can interact with monkeys and macaws. It’s a great choice if you want to see some nature without breaking a sweat, and it’s family-friendly, too.

Falmouth, Jamaica

Best Excursion: Rafting on the Martha Brae River or Visiting Dunn’s River Falls

Try bamboo rafting down the Martha Brae River to relax and soak up Jamaica’s natural beauty. You’ll float on a 30-foot bamboo raft, guided by a local who shares stories about the island along the way—totally chill and super scenic. 

Ready to get your feet wet? Head to Dunn’s River Falls, where you can climb the terraced waterfalls (don’t worry, guides have your back) and cool off in the natural pools. Just bring water shoes, as the rocks can be slippery!

Alternative Excursion: Plantation Tour with Traditional Jamaican Cuisine

Want to dive into Jamaican history and flavors? A plantation tour is the way to go. Tour historic estates, delve into Jamaica’s colonial past, and savor authentic dishes like jerk chicken and fried plantains. 

It’s a low-key way to experience the culture and savor local flavors, all while taking in the gorgeous countryside.

How to Choose Between Eastern and Western Caribbean Itineraries

Priorities: Cultural Immersion (Eastern) vs. Adventure and Natural Beauty (Western)

Eastern Caribbean: Culture & Exploration

• Perfect for anyone who loves exploring local cultural history and trying new flavors.

What You’ll Find:

• Historic Cities: Wander through charming streets with bright, colorful buildings – perfect for snapping pics! Most spots have guided walking tours if you want the inside scoop.
• Lively Markets: Check out the bustling local markets packed with fresh produce, handmade crafts, and tasty street food. Great for grabbing unique souvenirs or trying local snacks!
• Rich History: Dive into the past with visits to old forts, museums, or historic landmarks – there's always a story waiting to be discovered.

Western Caribbean: Adventure & Natural Beauty

• Perfect for thrill-seekers who want a mix of action and stunning scenery.

What You’ll Experience:

• Ziplining Through Rainforests: Soar above the treetops on a zipline – it's a total adrenaline rush! Most tours offer different courses, so you can pick how daring you want to be.
• Snorkeling Vibrant Coral Reefs: Grab your snorkel gear and dive into crystal-clear waters. You'll swim alongside colorful fish and rays and maybe even spot a sea turtle.
• Hiking Ancient Mayan Ruins: Lace up your hiking boots and explore these incredible ruins. Many spots have guided walks to help you understand the historical significance while you take in the amazing views.
• Vibe: Packed with outdoor adventures and jaw-dropping natural beauty – ideal for those who want to stay active and soak up everything the islands offer.

Activities on Eastern and Western Caribbean Cruises

Eastern Caribbean Cruises

• Vibes: Super chill and laid-back

Popular Activities:

• Beach Relaxation: Kick back on soft, sandy beaches – perfect for catching up on your tan or diving into a good book.
• Wandering Through Towns: Stroll through charming, colorful streets and check out the local shops and cafes. It’s great for laid-back exploring!
• Casual Island Tours: Hop on a guided tour to get a taste of island life without the rush—think scenic drives, local history, and opportunities to sample the local eats.
• Ideal for: Anyone looking to take it easy, slow down, and soak up the relaxed island vibes.

Western Caribbean Cruises

• Vibes: Non-stop adventure and excitement
  

Popular Activities:

• Snorkeling Trips: Dive into crystal-clear waters and get up close with vibrant coral reefs and tropical fish. These trips are perfect for those who love underwater adventures!
• Hiking Trails: Hike jungle trails or coastal paths for epic views and exercise. It’s a great way to explore the area's natural beauty.
• Exploring Ancient Ruins: Check out historic Mayan ruins or other archaeological sites. You’ll feel like you’re stepping back in time!
• Ideal for: Travelers who want excitement and variety, with something new and active to do daily.

Cruise Duration and Types of Ports Visited

Eastern Caribbean Cruises:

• It tends to be longer with more sea days.
• It’s ideal for extra relaxation and enjoying onboard amenities.
• Perfect if you want more time to unwind.

Western Caribbean Cruises:

• Typically shorter with more action-packed stops.
• You’ll hit the ground running, hopping from port to port.
• Great for a quick, adventure-filled getaway when time is limited.

Budget Considerations

For those watching their budget, Western Caribbean cruises are a win. They often come with shorter itineraries, which means lower costs; you’ll still pack in many experiences. 

Eastern cruises can be a bit more pricey, but you’re paying for a more relaxed pace and the chance to explore multiple islands. It’s a case of spending a bit more for that extra laid-back, island-hopping adventure.